ELK – Constructed Spins / Recursions?
This is a question for industry professionals within this community and/or people with basic coding knowledge.
While exploring various slot providers for their unique pros and cons, I noticed something intriguing about ELK Studios that stood out to me. Initially, I couldn’t pinpoint it, but as I observed their spin mechanics more closely, a pattern began to emerge.
In ELK’s games — particularly the base game spins with moderate wins in the range of 15x to 50x — the spins often feel blatantly constructed. Specifically, the slot seems to repeatedly use improbable mechanics during these “spending spins” to escalate the win to a predetermined size.
From this, I hypothesize that ELK might be using a system where the outcome of a spin is determined first (e.g., “dead spin,” “win > 20x,” “win > 0.8x”), and then a scenario is recursively constructed to fit that outcome. This approach might work something like this (in simplified pseudocode):
def play_spin(): determined_output = determine_output() # RNG-based
if determined_output > 0:
generate_win(0, determined_output)
else:
return deadSpin();
def generate_win(current_win, target_win):
current_win += trigger_unlikely_mechanic() # Simulates reels, cascades, etc.
if current_win >= target_win:
return current_win
else:
return generate_win(current_win, target_win)
While this approach is mathematically valid and no less fair than a traditional symbol-probability-based model, it gives off a “scripted” vibe when observed. Watching these mechanics unfold repeatedly feels less organic and more preordained, which can detract from the gameplay experience.
My questions are:
- Am I wrong in my interpretation of ELK’s system?
- Do other providers use a similar recursive approach?
- Is this even the industry standard, or are there alternative models being widely used?
I’d appreciate any insights or clarifications from those familiar with slot game design or coding.
I'm about 200 horus (120k-140k) spins on ELK games, some with bonus hunt some without. I didn't hit any 1000x or bigger win.
Plus, I've discovered 3 pairs of identical rounds so far. Video proofs:
Nitropolis 4: https://youtu.be/CLGQijUmh_s
Nitropolis 3: https://youtu.be/Ta8qv5ooWmw
Tropicool 2 Bonus buy: https://youtu.be/2NEwzqlH0D0
And now I'm working on collecting some data to analysis, with a target sample size of 100k spins no extra bet, since I'm going to lose 6000x/€1200, and that's pretty much my budget on ELK games for the first half of 2025. Here's my current progress:
I download my bet history archive from Stake, then ask Chat GPT to write a program and analyze it. Although I do need to manually record all the bonus I triggered, as well as the result.
Click to expand the following part to see:
[spoiler title="Gameplay history"]
Input filename (leave empty for sample.csv): ELK_gameplay_2024
Round count: 20760
Games played:
2,530 rounds on Katmandu X
2,112 rounds on Propaganda
1,830 rounds on Pirots 3
1,485 rounds on Cygnus 3
1,327 rounds on Cygnus 4
1,282 rounds on Buffalo Toro
1,189 rounds on Nitropolis 5
980 rounds on Cluster Kingdom
877 rounds on Pirots X
835 rounds on Avalon Gold
750 rounds on oXygen
750 rounds on Katmandu Gold
682 rounds on Cygnus 2
650 rounds on Bompers
616 rounds on Rogue Rats of Nitropolis
581 rounds on Tropicool 2
502 rounds on Nitropolis 2
500 rounds on Nitropolis 3
431 rounds on Pirots
400 rounds on Valhall Gold
251 rounds on Reindeer Royale
200 rounds on Ashoka
Wagered: 20,760.00x
Total result: -2,775.15x
Expected: -1,160.96x
Volatility: 6.10
Hit frequency: 23.96%
Win frequency (>= Cost): 10.90%
Win frequency+ (> Cost): 10.52%
Win 15x:
Freq: 281 in 20760 (1 in 73.88)
Total value: 10,041.35 (55.83% of total win)
Avg value: 35.73
Win 25x:
Freq: 152 in 20760 (1 in 136.58)
Total value: 7,591.65 (42.21% of total win)
Avg value: 49.95
Win 50x:
Freq: 36 in 20760 (1 in 576.67)
Total value: 3,594.75 (19.99% of total win)
Avg value: 99.85
Win 75x:
Freq: 18 in 20760 (1 in 1153.33)
Total value: 2,548.65 (14.17% of total win)
Avg value: 141.59
Win 100x:
Freq: 12 in 20760 (1 in 1730.00)
Total value: 2,027.90 (11.28% of total win)
Avg value: 168.99
Win 150x:
Freq: 5 in 20760 (1 in 4152.00)
Total value: 1,180.20 (6.56% of total win)
Avg value: 236.04
Win 200x:
Freq: 2 in 20760 (1 in 10380.00)
Total value: 676.30 (3.76% of total win)
Avg value: 338.15
Win 250x:
Freq: 1 in 20760 (1 in 20760.00)
Total value: 469.30 (2.61% of total win)
Avg value: 469.30
Win 300x:
Freq: 1 in 20760 (1 in 20760.00)
Total value: 469.30 (2.61% of total win)
Avg value: 469.30
Win 500x or higher: didn't happen
Bonus rounds:
Win 25.20x from Regular Bonus
Win 37.60x from Regular Bonus
Win 114.00x from Regular Bonus
Win 32.60x from Regular Bonus
Win 35.00x from Bossfight (Nitropolis5)
Win 44.00x from Regular Bonus
Win 62.35x from Regular Bonus
Win 11.60x from Regular Bonus
Win 117.30x from Regular Bonus
Win 94.05x from Regular Bonus
Win 31.20x from Regular Bonus
Win 33.60x from Regular Bonus
Win 36.35x from Regular Bonus
Win 11.00x from Mini Bonus (Cluster Kingdom)
Win 31.45x from Regular Bonus
Win 49.55x from Regular Bonus
Win 98.55x from Regular Bonus
Win 48.70x from Regular Bonus
Win 46.15x from Regular Bonus
Win 19.20x from Regular Bonus
Win 19.50x from Regular Bonus
Win 10.10x from Regular Bonus
Win 28.95x from Regular Bonus
Win 55.95x from Regular Bonus
Win 38.55x from Regular Bonus
Win 154.15x from Regular Bonus
Win 114.20x from Regular Bonus
Win 469.30x from Super Bonus (Pirots X)
Win 62.70x from Regular Bonus
Win 56.40x from Regular Bonus
Win 19.65x from Cygnus 3 Wheel (Crashed)
Win 166.65x from Cygnus 3 Wheel
Win 18.90x from Cygnus 3 Wheel (Crashed)
Win 84.90x from Cygnus 3 Wheel
Win 23.75x from Cygnus 3 Wheel (Crashed)
Win 14.05x from Cygnus 3 Wheel (Crashed)
Win 75.50x from Cygnus 3 Wheel
Win 126.90x from Regular Bonus
Win 68.70x from Regular Bonus
Win 61.80x from Regular Bonus
Win 52.85x from Regular Bonus
Win 26.10x from Regular Bonus
Win 119.60x from Regular Bonus
Win 58.35x from Regular Bonus
Win 51.40x from Regular Bonus
Win 47.10x from Regular Bonus
Win 59.50x from Regular Bonus
Win 17.10x from Regular Bonus
Win 20.95x from Regular Bonus
Win 13.80x from Regular Bonus
Win 56.30x from Regular Bonus
Win 51.40x from Regular Bonus
Win 183.10x from Regular Bonus
Win 43.25x from Regular Bonus
Win 207.00x from Regular Bonus
Win 59.20x from Bossfight (Nitropolis5)
Win 20.15x from Bossfight (Nitropolis5)
Win 37.10x from Regular Bonus
Win 62.00x from Regular Bonus
Win 48.20x from Regular Bonus
Win 78.15x from Regular Bonus
Win 47.80x from Regular Bonus (Nitropilis 3)
Win 16.05x from Regular Bonus
Bonus freq: 63/20760 = 1 in 329.52 = 0.30%
Bonus total win: 4,026.50x (19.40% of total win)
Bonus avg win: 63.91x
Process finished with exit code 0[/spoiler]
This is a greate analysis, thank you!
Same rounds mean that elk is not using true rng?
I don't play elk slots much. But similar events occur in Pragmatic. Sometimes a single symbol or a single scatter is missing for a tumble, the game seems to stop suddenly and other symbols come instead of the symbol expected to fall. It seems suspicious to me that Pragmatic slots pause for such a short time.
Same rounds mean that elk is not using true rng?
If I can get 3 pairs of identical rounds, including a pair of identical bonus round, this can only means there's a very high chance all rounds are selected from a pre-built library.
Some rounds have a higher weight than others, such as that Nitropolis 4: Intentional scatters on first 2 reels but no bonus trigger, to annoy the player. ELK does such kind of thing pretty often, so it's no surprise they give such rounds a higher weight.
The main problem is their math. Jammin Jars are also pre scripted but it have a well balanced math. ELK games don't. From the win 100x ~(1/1.7k) and win 150x ~(1/4k) you can tell a lot. With that amount of spins you have a good chance of catching a 300x or 500x on any NLC slot.
Same rounds mean that elk is not using true rng?
If I can get 3 pairs of identical rounds, including a pair of identical bonus round, this can only means there's a very high chance all rounds are selected from a pre-built library.
Some rounds have a higher weight than others, such as that Nitropolis 4: Intentional scatters on first 2 reels but no bonus trigger, to annoy the player. ELK does such kind of thing pretty often, so it's no surprise they give such rounds a higher weight.
The main problem is their math. Jammin Jars are also pre scripted but it have a well balanced math. ELK games don't. From the win 100x ~(1/1.7k) and win 150x ~(1/4k) you can tell a lot. With that amount of spins you have a good chance of catching a 300x or 500x on any NLC slot.
if they going with this way, probably next years lost fans and players
@hxlohar 150x on 4000 spins, really annoying, bwb sharing ELK big wins on YouTube, that players must be super lucky. Just jammin jars pre scripted or all games from Push Gaming?
Is this even the industry standard, or are there alternative models being widely used?
Elk is European slot maker and you can play Elk games on more popular casinos. From this i found they models and scripts are suit for gambling standards. It is just my opinion 😊
this provider is so weird, it feels like it is a fake "extreme" volatility, every time you think you have a huge setup and it pays 100x only. btw 1000x is impossible xd