Community ›Gambling Industry › Push Gaming RTP Inconsistencies

Push Gaming RTP Inconsistencies

Started by Dorko 35 replies
Dorko
Degen
475 points
6 years ago
#1

I used to run a blog about slots in the past and have client area access to several game studios. Going through some of them today just out of curiosity I noticed that there is quite a significant disparity in the RTP compared to the value presented by Push Gaming and what the testing agency eCOGRA has calculated independently. Here are some examples:

Mystery Museum
Push Gaming RTP: 96.58% (97.04% With Power Gamble)
eCOGRA RTP: 97.64% (95.68% With Power Gamble)

Razor Shark
Push Gaming RTP: 96.70%
eCOGRA RTP: 96.35%

The Shadow Order
Push Gaming RTP: 96.51%-96.98%
eCOGRA RTP: 94.88%-98.34%

Jammin’ Jars
Push Gaming RTP: 96.83%
eCOGRA RTP: 95.17%

Wild Swarm
Push Gaming RTP: 97.03%
eCOGRA RTP: 96.35%

Fat Rabbit
Push Gaming RTP: 96.45%
eCOGRA RTP: 96.74%

I just want to make it clear that I do not claim to fully understand what all of this means. It’s totally possible that these type of inconsistencies are common and well within the accepted spectrum so to speak. Still, as a player it’s a little bit disturbing that there is a possibility (when looking at these numbers) that RTP can be so “off”. Take Jammin’ Jars for example. 96.83% is GREAT by any standards, but 95.17% is not.

I think it’s really cool of Push Gaming to be transparent like this and hope they don’t feel the need to stop that. As a writer myself I know there are studios that are a bit shady and never share any sort of information with affiliates at all. But I guess I am looking for some answers here. What does this mean? When Push Gaming displays 96.38% RTP for Jammin’ Jars in their paytable, is that the actual RTP or what is?

Admin: I edited the title from “false” to “inconsistencies” since you may be jumping to conclusions.

  1. Fashion Victim
    Degen
    306 points
    6 years ago
    #2

    Um I would also like an answer to this.

  2. Nick77
    High Roller
    534 points
    6 years ago
    #3

    Well, either push gaming suck at maths or ecogra does.

  3. Carpe Diem
    Degen
    277 points
    6 years ago
    #4

    Nice find! Would like to hear an explanation for this. The rtp in the power gamble feature is huge.

  4. nutz
    High Roller
    530 points
    6 years ago
    #5

    Is it possible that Push gaming runs more simulated spins than ecogra for example or vice versa? Just guessing here. What makes it baffling to me is how Push gaming can display their own rtp and not required to display the one measured by the testing agency? Wouldn't that be a requirement? Otherwise game developers can make up whichever rtp they want?

  5. Luckyshot
    Degen
    497 points
    6 years ago
    #6

    I might sound naive but PG are legitimate. I don't think they would be so stupid to publish these documents if they were systematically cheating. There's just no way I can believe that. I mean no offence, but it's more likely that it is you who don't know how to interpret the info as you have stated yourself.

  6. WildWinner
    Beginner
    36 points
    6 years ago
    #7

    Hi - not a Push Gaming rep but am familiar with the certification process.

    The job of the test house when it comes to RTP is to verify that the RTP Push Gaming is publishing is as expected within statistical confidence. The likely scenario here is that Push Gaming have calculated their RTP exactly (using a computer program to simulate every single outcome), or they have calculated it based on billions of simulations. ecogra probably ran less game rounds (say 100 million), but their results were within a 95% (or 90%) confidence interval of what Push Gaming have published.  As games become more volatile, the 'confidence interval' becomes larger. The likes of Jammin' Jars and Razor Shark are very volatile and as such, the large differences seen above are still 'within confidence'. 

    To me seems like a lack of due diligence on ecogras part as such large confidence intervals can leave room for error. This is of course, unless Push Gaming have some how managed to get their games in the industry with RTP fails in the report (unlikely). 

  7. Dorko
    Degen
    475 points
    6 years ago
    #8

    @wildwinner thanks for the input. What you're saying makes total sense although I assumed that the "official" RTP was always coming from the testing agency and not the game providers themselves.

  8. CoinMaster
    High Roller
    595 points
    6 years ago
    #9

    This needs answers for sure. I mean, we all bitch about casinos lowering the rtp by 1% or whatever and here we see 96% rtp potentially being 95% without us knowing so?

  9. WildWinner
    Beginner
    36 points
    6 years ago
    #10

    @dorko Hi. Unfortunately not. The role of the test house is to verify the RTP rather than calculate it themselves. This isn't always the case, but usually what happens is the provider will spend weeks (sometimes months) putting together the math for a game and testing it to calculate the exact RTP or as close to it as possible. When it goes to the test house, they will generation simulations using a simulator that directly uses the providers RNG and game code. They test enough to be confident (statistically confident) that the extensive work done by the provider is correct. Rather than testing enough to recalculate the exact RTP. Games are becoming more and more complex, and so it takes quite a lot of time to carry out these calculations. For more simple games, the test house may be able to simply use excel to recalculate the RTP exactly. In this case, if the RTP is different from the providers then the provider will be told to update their calculations and RTP.

You must be logged in to reply.