@wildwinner thank you for explaining. So it seems when it comes to RTP, we have to the game developer's word for it and while we have test houses RTP could potentially be off by as much as 2%? I don't know how to look at it any other way. The numbers I presented in my initial post are so inconsistent. If it was off by 0.1-0.2% I would have been ok with it, but not by this much. It's maths after all so one would think it should be possible to measure more accurately?
@dorko yes you're right. So what I would say here is one of the following has happened:
1. egocra haven't ran enough game rounds to verify the RTP given it's volatility. Statistically speaking the results pass, but for our eyes you're right - it looks somewhat off.
2. Push gaming RTP actually failed, but have somehow got the games in the market anyway (incredibly unlikely!).
Would be interesting to see if a representative does respond. It could well be an error somewhere in the process.
@wildwinner I'm sure Push Gaming will be able to shed some light on this eventually. At least I hope so. I don't think badly of them and have no ill will. In fact, I find them to be a rather wholesome little studio so I don't want to cause them any harm. There is no such agenda here. I just found this info by pure chance and looking for answers now because it might be an industry wide issue?
In this case it's the other way around. The developer list it as 96.24% while I assume they could have listed it as 96.84% which would have looked better for them? I think it's just me not understanding how this works and I don't want to draw the wrong conclusions.
Hi all, apologies for the very late entry to the party on this one.
I work in the marketing dept at Push Gaming and was just made aware of this thread and wanted to address it. One of the members had pretty much hit the nail on the head in a previous comment however can't hurt to clarify.
Our RTP is tracked over billions of spins and that is the RTP we publish in our game information and in the game pages. Running so many simulations takes a huge amount of time. When we send the game over to a test house for certification they run a smaller sample set although still a huge number of spins. As accredited test houses they of course have defined requirements to ensure all tests are fit for purpose.
Given the much larger sample size you can expect our RTP to be the more accurate which is why this is the published number. Also to keep in mind is that you could have a game certified by multiple test houses - One example of this may be different markets being served by different test houses so using any other RTPs would likely create more confusion as it's unlikely they will ever come back exactly the same.
Hope that makes some sense. Sorry again for the delay on this, we are trying to find a way to get more presence here to be able to answer any questions and maybe ask a few questions ourselves. In the meantime give me a nudge if I can help with something or you can always email us at info@pushgaming.com
@darrenpg thank you so much for taking the time to come here and explain it to us. Just to point out, I never suspected there to be any foul play going on, I was just curious and trying to make some sense of it. Now I feel educated and know better. Thank you again :)
No worries it's a valid question especially at present with different RTP versions becoming more common. Maybe we should do an article with the big win board guys where we can give our thoughts on that topic in more detail. Enjoy the weekend.
@wildwinner thank you for explaining. So it seems when it comes to RTP, we have to the game developer's word for it and while we have test houses RTP could potentially be off by as much as 2%? I don't know how to look at it any other way. The numbers I presented in my initial post are so inconsistent. If it was off by 0.1-0.2% I would have been ok with it, but not by this much. It's maths after all so one would think it should be possible to measure more accurately?
@dorko yes you're right. So what I would say here is one of the following has happened:
1. egocra haven't ran enough game rounds to verify the RTP given it's volatility. Statistically speaking the results pass, but for our eyes you're right - it looks somewhat off.
2. Push gaming RTP actually failed, but have somehow got the games in the market anyway (incredibly unlikely!).
Would be interesting to see if a representative does respond. It could well be an error somewhere in the process.
@wildwinner I'm sure Push Gaming will be able to shed some light on this eventually. At least I hope so. I don't think badly of them and have no ill will. In fact, I find them to be a rather wholesome little studio so I don't want to cause them any harm. There is no such agenda here. I just found this info by pure chance and looking for answers now because it might be an industry wide issue?
I just checked a random Quickspin slot, they also use eCOGRA.
Nero's Fortune
Quickspin RTP: 96.24%
eCOGRA RTP: 96.84%
In this case it's the other way around. The developer list it as 96.24% while I assume they could have listed it as 96.84% which would have looked better for them? I think it's just me not understanding how this works and I don't want to draw the wrong conclusions.
So what's happening with this case? Push Gaming just ignoring it?
Hi all, apologies for the very late entry to the party on this one.
I work in the marketing dept at Push Gaming and was just made aware of this thread and wanted to address it. One of the members had pretty much hit the nail on the head in a previous comment however can't hurt to clarify.
Our RTP is tracked over billions of spins and that is the RTP we publish in our game information and in the game pages. Running so many simulations takes a huge amount of time. When we send the game over to a test house for certification they run a smaller sample set although still a huge number of spins. As accredited test houses they of course have defined requirements to ensure all tests are fit for purpose.
Given the much larger sample size you can expect our RTP to be the more accurate which is why this is the published number. Also to keep in mind is that you could have a game certified by multiple test houses - One example of this may be different markets being served by different test houses so using any other RTPs would likely create more confusion as it's unlikely they will ever come back exactly the same.
Hope that makes some sense. Sorry again for the delay on this, we are trying to find a way to get more presence here to be able to answer any questions and maybe ask a few questions ourselves. In the meantime give me a nudge if I can help with something or you can always email us at info@pushgaming.com
Thanks!
Darren
@darrenpg thank you so much for taking the time to come here and explain it to us. Just to point out, I never suspected there to be any foul play going on, I was just curious and trying to make some sense of it. Now I feel educated and know better. Thank you again :)
@darrenpg when do we get to see Jammin Jars 2? 😎
@dorko
No worries it's a valid question especially at present with different RTP versions becoming more common. Maybe we should do an article with the big win board guys where we can give our thoughts on that topic in more detail. Enjoy the weekend.
@zim-zum
If I told you i'd have to kill you ;) Watch this space..